The Los Angeles Dodgers are playing it safe with their roster, and it's a decision that could spark some debate among fans and analysts alike. Here's the scoop:
Dodgers' Dilemma: Keep or Trade?
Teoscar Hernandez, a powerful outfielder, was rumored to be on the trading block earlier this winter. With the recent addition of Kyle Tucker, a natural question arises: will the Dodgers part ways with Hernandez to make room for the new talent? But here's the twist—according to renowned insiders Ken Rosenthal and Alden Gonzalez, it's more probable that Hernandez will remain a Dodger when the season begins.
The Dodgers' strategy seems to be shifting Hernandez to left field, allowing Tucker to claim his usual spot in right. This move would impact the center field position, where Andy Pages and Tommy Edman are the primary contenders, with Alex Call as a backup. Interestingly, Edman is also a potential solution for the unsettled second base position, competing with the likes of Miguel Rojas, Hyeseong Kim, Alex Freeland, and new addition Andy Ibanez. A reunion with Enrique Hernandez later in the offseason is also a possibility.
Back in December, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts and GM Brandon Gomes played down the idea of trading Hernandez. Even Rosenthal's initial report suggested it was unlikely, given the Dodgers signed Hernandez to a three-year, $66 million contract just a year ago. The financial breakdown of this deal is worth noting: $12 million in 2026, $14.5 million in 2027, and a $6.5 million buyout of a $15 million club option for 2028. With a $23 million signing bonus and a $10 million salary for 2025 already paid, the remaining $33 million over two years becomes a more manageable figure for potential trade partners.
And this is where it gets controversial—the Dodgers, known for their deep pockets, could have gained some luxury tax relief and outfield flexibility by trading Hernandez. Players like Alex Call or Tommy Edman might have seen more action, and the Dodgers' top prospects, including Josue De Paula, could have had a better shot at a Major League debut this year. But the Dodgers are prioritizing stability, avoiding the risks of relying on unproven players as they aim for their third consecutive World Series title.
Hernandez's trade value might also be a factor. After a decent 2025 season with 25 homers, his batting performance dipped in 2026, with a .247/.284/.454 slash line and a career-low 4.8% walk rate. His defense is also considered subpar, limiting his overall value.
While the Dodgers might not trade Hernandez, they have the depth to explore other trade options. Rosenthal hints that right-hander Bobby Miller or minor league outfielder Ryan Ward could be on the trading block. Miller, once a top pitching prospect, has struggled with control issues, while Ward, despite his success in Triple-A, might not fit into the Dodgers' long-term vision.
So, will the Dodgers stick with their current roster or make a surprise move? The team's decision to keep Hernandez might be a safe bet, but it leaves room for debate. What do you think? Is this the right move for the Dodgers, or should they have explored trading Hernandez more aggressively? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
